Temporal variability in the response to thermal stress in the red gorgonian, P. clavata: Insights form common garden experiments

Abstract

Recurrent mass mortality events (MMEs) linked to marine heatwaves (MHWs) have been observed in the Mediterranean Sea affecting thousands of kilometers of coastline. Coralligenous habitats were among the most impacted during these events. Information on how the exposure to recurrent MHWs is affecting the coralligenous is critical to anticipate the consequences of climate change and implement actions to enhance their resilience. Combining field surveys with experiments in controlled conditions allowed to dilucidate the differential responses to thermal stress among species, populations and individuals and to explore the spatial and taxonomic variability response to thermal stress linked to MHWs. Yet, the temporal variability in the response to thermal stress remains to be characterized. Thus, we aim to fill this gap focusing on the temporal variability in the response to thermal stress of the coralligenous key habitat-forming species Paramuricea clavata (Plexauridae). We replicated thermal stress experiments during 3 consecutive years following a common garden setup (control vs. thermal stress) involving the same individuals from the same three populations. Considering different phenotypic responses including the level of tissue necrosis during the time of the experiment and the survival of the individuals, we found that the average percentage of tissue necrosis per population variated greatly across years while the probability of survival was considerably reduced in 2017. During the experiments, several individuals from the 3 populations systematically showed reduced level of tissue necrosis suggesting resistance to thermal stress. Overall our data will contribute to help better inform further conservation strategies of habitat-forming coral species in the Mediterranean Sea