English   español  
Por favor, use este identificador para citar o enlazar a este item: http://hdl.handle.net/10261/9833
Compartir / Impacto:
Add this article to your Mendeley library MendeleyBASE
Visualizar otros formatos: MARC | Dublin Core | RDF | ORE | MODS | METS | DIDL

Flew on Entitlements and Justice

AutorPeña, Lorenzo
Palabras claveIgualdad
Antony Flew
Derechos igualitarismo
Colectivismo distribucionismo
Grados de legitimidad
Antony Flew
Rights egalitarianism
Degrees of legitimacy
Fecha de publicación1989
CitaciónInternational Journal of Moral and Social Studies 4/3 (autumn 1989), pp. 259-63
ResumenIn «Equality, yes, surely; but Justice?», Antony Flew argues that egalitarianism and collectivism are incompatible with the concept of justice, since the usual concept of justice is that of giving everyone his due (or his own). That concept is intrinsically backward-looking; you cannot assign everyone his own by gratuitously presupposing that nothing is his own and that a fresh start is to be made. As against such a view, I maintain that, in a fairly obvious sense, all goods are `up for grabs'. Obviously not all prior holdings are legitimate -- and so not everything a person has, or holds, or enjoys, is (legitimately, justly) his own (Flew himself implicitly recognizes that point). What a distributionist would then point out is that the needy's right to be treated so as to have their fulfilment as human beings enhanced overcomes or supersedes whatever purported `entitlements' have thus far been bestowed upon the small minority of the well-to-do -- and hence that none of the goods to be (re)distributed is due to those few people. There may be degrees of legitimacy and of illegitimacy, so much so that some actions or holdings may be to some extent legitimate and yet up to a point illegitimate, owing to which a fresh redistribution of the goods thus held might be both to some extent just and to some extent unjust.
Aparece en las colecciones: (CCHS-IFS) Artículos
Ficheros en este ítem:
Fichero Descripción Tamaño Formato  
flew.pdf32,02 kBAdobe PDFVista previa
Mostrar el registro completo

NOTA: Los ítems de Digital.CSIC están protegidos por copyright, con todos los derechos reservados, a menos que se indique lo contrario.